There's no denying that Peter Dinklage is a great actor. But there's also no denying that for the most part his performance in Destiny was lacklustre. While some of his line were amusing and memorable, that's more due to us laughing at him rather than with him. So why was that the case?
I think the reason is that Dinklage is a very VISUAL actor. Watch him on Game of Thrones, then try watching some of his scenes with your eyes closed. His voice doesn't actually change that much whether he is sad or angry or happy (except for maybe that amazing trial scene), but his expressions and physicality really sells the performance and the emotion he is trying to convey. That's what makes him so good.
Obviously, in Destiny, we didn't have that, since he was just floating sphere with no face or body. Couple that with attempting to sound robotic and some somewhat dubious script lines, and you have a role that is not really suited to Dinklage at all. It was cool hearing a memorable voice and having a big name involved, but he really wasn't the best man for the job.
Nolan, on the other hand, has tons of experience with this kind of role. Voicing virtual characters is his profession, and you can really see it in the new Ghost's performance. Regardless of whether or not you actually like the sound of the new voice, I think there's no denying that the way he says the lines feels a lot more natural and carries more emotion. I think that, with time, people will get used to the way he sounds now, and will realise that it's actually an improvement. I guarantee that if the Ghost had had this voice from the start, there would have been no complaints.
Can i just say the Nolan worst voice yet.
I played a mission yesterday and toward the end of the Ghost voice it changes as he make a kinda joke. i was like WTF the voice just changed. not sure if they recorded it in 2 parts then stuck them together but i was shocked and had to run the mission again and put my gaming headset up full just to make sure.
his tone is inconsistent and changed most of the time.
if i was a voice actor and done this for a living after a performus like this one i would be a bit worried about other jobs,
like a famous actor doing a bad movie with a bad director can rune your career